MackCollier.com

by Leave a Comment

My Substack Conversion Rate Went From 0.5% to 13% in Six Months, Here’s How

substack conversion rate I joined Substack in June of 2024. After 14 months of writing on Substack, I had over 1,000 subscribers, and a conversion rate of 0.5%.

It wasn’t pretty.

What really made it frustrating was, I was following the advice that all the Substack ‘experts’ gave.

They said post regularly, write Notes constantly, get to 500 or 1,000 subscribers, then you can think about a Paid tier.

I did all those things.  I pushed to grow my number of subscribers as quickly as possible.

When I hit 1,000 subscribers, I stepped back and looked at my progress. After spending 14 months on the platform, I had 1,000 subscribers and 7 of those were Paid.

I had about $300 in revenue after 14 months. I knew something had to change.

So I dug into my numbers.  I realized it took me over a year to get to 1,000 subscribers. Then it hit me: In order to double my revenue, I would have to get another 1,000 subscribers. Even if I could dramatically increase my subscriber growth rate, it would still likely take months to get another 1,000 subscribers, and another 7 Paid subscribers.

The Shift That Changed Everything

Suddenly, inspiration struck: What if, instead of trying to increase my subscriber growth rate, I improved my conversion rate?  My conversion rate at the time was a paltry 0.5%.  Why?  Because I didn’t have a conversion strategy! Plus, I had been listening to the Substack ‘experts’, and none of them mentioned conversion rates.  They just said get to 1,000 subscribers as fast as you could.  Well I did that, and had almost nothing to show for it.

Then it hit me: I didn’t need more free subscribers, I just needed to do a better job of converting the free subscribers I had to Paid!

Immediately, I started working to improve my Substack conversion rate.  The first 1,000 subscribers led to 7 Paid subscribers, about a 0.5% conversion rate. The next 300 free subscribers I got, I converted 39 of them.

My Substack conversion rate for the first 1,000 subscribers was 0.5%.  For the next 300? It was 13%.

The System I Built to Facilitate Growth

Most ‘growth experts’ on Substack will tell you that your top priority should be to acquire as many free subscribers as possible, as quickly as possible. And don’t even think about launching a Paid tier until you have at least 500 subscribers.

As I learned the hard way, this advice is completely wrong.

Most Substack writers focus on collecting free subscribers as quickly as possible.  The smarter ones focus on building an engagement strategy first.

Both approaches are wrong.

As I learned, the ideal system to build revenue on Substack has three phases:

1 – Design a content strategy that gives your Substack its focus and positions you correctly

2 – Design a conversion experience that builds on the focus and positioning you developed with your content

3 – Design an engagement strategy that layers over your content and conversion strategies

 

Increase Your Substack Conversion Rate Today

I teach my Paid subscribers how to build this system step by step. The same system I have used to increase my revenue by 703% over the last 6 months.

Here’s a free tip: You build the engagement strategy last instead of first because you want your content and conversion strategies to vet potential subscribers for you.

Most Substack creators do the reverse: They focus on engagement first, and bring in as many subscribers as possible. Then later on, they think about building a content strategy. Once they start focusing, some subscribers will leave (“Hey, I didn’t sign up for this!”), then when they later introduce a Paid tier, even more subscribers will unsubscribe.

By creating the content and conversion strategies first, you allow incoming subscribers to vet themselves.  They can see for themselves what your focus is, how you are positioned, and the type of Paid tier you offer.  So when they subscribe, they are already signaling that they are more interested in they type of content and Paid tier you offer.

In 14 months following the ‘expert’ advice, I built 1,000 subscribers and made $300.

In the 6 months since I stopped listening to them, my revenue increased by 703%.

The difference wasn’t talent. It wasn’t luck. It was a system.

That system is inside Backstage Pass. Every piece of it. The content strategy that positions you correctly from day one. The conversion strategy that turns free subscribers into paying ones. The engagement strategy that accelerates everything.

The writers who start building this system today will be the ones positioned perfectly when Substack’s growth window opens later this year.

The ones who wait will be starting from scratch when everyone else is already running.

by Leave a Comment

A Solid Conversion Strategy is Vital on Substack, Here’s the Proof

Since June of 2024, I’ve been publishing Backstage Pass on Substack. I’ve been having an absolute blast doing so. Today I wanted to share one of the most impactful lessons I’ve learned: The value of a good conversion strategy.

The Value of a Solid Conversion Strategy

In August of 2025, I focused on tightening my content strategy for my Substack publication, Backstage Pass. The improvement I saw in views, readership and engagement was almost immediate.

Around this time, I wrote two posts that did very well for me.  The first came in August, a post for my Paid subscribers on the conversion strategy that Spotify uses to convert a staggering 40% of its free users to Premium. To this day, this post remains my most viewed and profitable Substack post written.

A couple of weeks later, I wrote a post for all my subscribers (free and Paid) on 4 psychological triggers that content creators can use to get more engagement. This post had a lot of engagement (thank goodness, given the topic), and a lot of views.

But it didn’t convert any free subscribers to Paid. So I asked ChatGPT to analyze this post and tell me why it didn’t convert.

GPT said the post didn’t covert because first, I didn’t include a paywall.  Second, I gave away all the information for free.

In short, there was no reason for a free subscriber to convert to Paid, as I had given them all the information for free, and I wasn’t asking them to convert.

This post had no conversion strategy. In fact, my entire Substack had no real conversion strategy. I had no formal strategy for converting a free reader into a paying subscriber.

This was in September. Prior to that, my conversion rate on Substack was 0.5%.  For reference, most Substacks have a conversion rate in the 1-3% range. The best-performing Substacks hit 5%, and as you get above 5%, you get into more rarified air, with fewer and fewer publications hitting this mark.

I suspect there are few, if any, substacks that are matching or surpassing a 10% conversion rate at scale.

When I started building a conversion strategy for Backstage Pass, it’s conversion rate at that time was 0.5%.

However…the conversion rate for Backstage Pass since September 1st is 14.5%.

Think about that for a minute: Before creating and implementing a conversion strategy, I converted 0.5% of my free subscribers to Paid. Since implementing a solid conversion strategy, I am converting 11.3% of my free subscribers to Paid.

An increased conversion rate from 0.5% to 14.5%.

Here’s what has happened to revenue in that timeframe:

revenue increase on Substack due to solid conversion strategy

The first challenge was creating a solid content strategy. I did that.

The second challenge was creating a solid conversion strategy that would leverage the content strategy to realize a 10% conversion rate.  I am doing that now.

The final challenge will be maintaining a double-digit conversion rate as I scale.

I am documenting this entire process on Backstage Pass. Paid subscribers get access to teardowns of what has worked for me, so they apply these methods to their own publication and see similar results.

Subscribe today, so you can turn your Substack from a hopeful side-hustle to a profitable business in 2026: