MackCollier.com

  • Blog
  • Mack’s Bio
  • Work With Mack
    • See Mack’s Work
  • Buy Think Like a Rock Star
  • Book Mack to Speak

November 6, 2013 by Mack Collier

Here’s Why Your Loyalty Program Isn’t Working

6783727344_ae13545b3c_z

A loyalty program is a marketing tactic designed by a company to promote and encourage future purchases from customers.  A very simple example of this is punch cards that many retailers offer.  A local fast food chain offers a punch card and every time you buy a lunch buffet, you get a punch.  When your card has 10 punches, then you get a free buffet.  Effectively, you buy 10 meals to get an 11th one free.

Unfortunately, these type of programs don’t build loyalty to the brand, they build loyalty to the offer.

Here’s why:  what the company views as a reward, the customer views as a purchase incentive.  While the company views each punch of the card as a reward, the customer knows that the reward is actually the free meal that comes after the card has 10 punches.  The customer sees that each punch is an incentive, and each punch brings the customer closer to filling the card, which also makes them more likely to want to eat more meals at this retailer in order to complete the card.

But what happens to that customer’s loyalty level when the card is full?  Then they get their free meal, and a new card.  In other words, they now have to start over.  Which effectively means the customer’s loyalty level toward the offer resets as well, to a much lower level.

In order to build loyalty to the brand you need to offer rewards that come after the purchase but are not dependent on a particular purchase.  And it helps if the reward is unexpected.

For example, let’s say that you ate lunch at the same fast food chain in the above example, but you didn’t have a punch card.  In fact, let’s say you ate there 3 times over the next 2 weeks.  On the 4th visit when you went to pay for the meal the owner says ‘This one’s on the house, thanks for your business!’  That reward was totally unexpected and it helps build loyalty to the brand.  Which means your chances of  eating there more often just increased.

So if you want to create more loyal customers, here’s your cheat sheet:

1 – Don’t offer incentives.  Incentives don’t increase loyalty to the brand they increase loyalty to the offer to which they are attached.

2 – Offer rewards after the purchase that the customer does not expect.  The customer views this as your brand showing its appreciation for the customer’s business.

3 – Recognize the people that are helping to build your business and say thank you.  These people don’t need incentives because they are already loyal to your brand.  Say ‘Thank you!’ (and mean it) and you’ll create more loyal customers.

 

PS: Kathy has a fabulous comment on this topic from earlier this year, it’s worth a read as well.

Pic via Flickr user steve_lodefink

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related


Discover more from MackCollier.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Filed Under: Brand Advocacy, Marketing, Think Like a Rockstar

About Mack Collier

My name is Mack Collier and I am a digital marketing and content strategist located in Alabama. Since 2006 I've helped companies of all sizes from startups to global brands such as Adobe, Dell and Ingersoll-Rand, create customer-centric programs, content and experiences. A long-time internet geek, I've been online since 1988 and began using social networking sites in 1991 when I joined Prodigy. Today, I help companies understand how new technologies like web3, crypto and artificial intelligence can integrate with existing marketing strategies to lead to exceptional customer experiences.

Comments

  1. Mandy Cat says

    November 11, 2013 at 6:26 am

    ” On the 4th visit ( .. to a fast food chain ..) when you went to pay for the meal the owner says ‘This one’s on the house, thanks for your business!’

    Any fast food chain with so few customers that the franchise owner recognizes you weeks later and remembers your last three visits is probably going out of business next week. Better grab that sandwich now!

  2. Corey Savage says

    November 12, 2013 at 11:54 am

    To truly be loyal to a company or brand it takes more than a “buy 10 get the 11th free” program, although that certainly won’t hurt either. A customer needs to feel appreciated and your tip about just saying “thank you” is sometimes the best way to gain loyalty!

Recent Posts

  • Understanding Substack’s Three Growth Stages
  • Blogging Isn’t Dead, it’s Morphed Into Substack
  • The Backstage Pass is Moving to Substack
  • Easter and the Three Eternal Gifts God Gives to Christians
  • Research: 97% of Loyalty Programs Fail Due to This Simple Design Flaw

Categories

Archives

Comment Policy

Be nice, be considerate, be friendly. Any comment that I feel doesn't meet these simple rules can and probably will be deleted.

Top Posts & Pages

  • Understanding Substack's Three Growth Stages
  • Case Study: Patagonia’s Brand Ambassador Program Focuses on Product Design and Development Over Sales
  • The Difference Between a Brand Ambassador and a Brand 'Spokesperson'
  • Why Did Jesus Send His Apostles Out With Nothing?
  • I Do Not Deserve to Suffer Like This...
  • How Much Does a Brand Ambassador Program Cost?
  • Blogging Isn't Dead, it's Morphed Into Substack
  • How to Compensate Brand Ambassadors Without Paying Them Money: A Real-World Example
  • How to Create Customer Loyalty After the Product Purchase
  • Research: 97% of Loyalty Programs Fail Due to This Simple Design Flaw

  • Blog
  • Mack’s Bio
  • Work With Mack
  • Buy Think Like a Rock Star
  • Book Mack to Speak

Copyright © 2025 · Executive Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

%d