MackCollier.com

  • Blog
  • Mack’s Bio
  • Work With Mack
    • See Mack’s Work
  • Buy Think Like a Rock Star
  • Book Mack to Speak

January 20, 2016 by Mack Collier

The Biggest Mistake That Brands Make When Working With Influencers

SocialGraphI just came across a quote in an eMarketer interview with an agency CEO that made me stop and shake my head:

“We don’t start to work with an influencer unless they have 50,000 combined followers across Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.”

This thinking is soooo backwards and lazy.  Picking an influencer isn’t about the size of their network, it’s the connections they have to that network.  I once wrote a post, and shared it on Twitter.  I had two people RT my link:

1 – An ‘influencer’ with over 80,000 followers on Twitter.

2 – A friend with 15,000 followers on Twitter.

The ‘influencer’ sent a grand total of THREE visitors to my blog.  The friend with 80% fewer followers sent over 300 visitors to my blog.

Why?  Because even though the friend had a far smaller network, her network trusted her and the content she shared.  I’ve been actively tracking referral traffic from Twitter for years, and I find that the people that send me the most referral traffic tend to have between 5,000 and 20,000 followers on Twitter.  At that size they are following fewer people and can develop more relationships and connections with their followers. Influencers with between 20,000 and 100,000 followers typically send LESS traffic to my blog.

So does that mean that number of followers is meaningless when evaluating which influencers to work with?  No, but it’s far less important than the levels of engagement that the influencer has with their audience.  And you have to dig deeper than just looking at RTs or Likes.  Look at how many comments they get.  Also look at how often they reply to followers and engage them.  You want to work with influencers that have a larger following, but who also are engaged with their following.  If I had to chose I’ll take working with the influencer with 15,000 followers that gets a ton of engagement with her network over the other influencer with 75,000 followers that never engages with or gets replies from his network.

Numbers aren’t everything.  Remember the whole point of this social media stuff is to be social.

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related


Discover more from MackCollier.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Filed Under: Brand Advocacy

About Mack Collier

My name is Mack Collier and I am a digital marketing and content strategist located in Alabama. Since 2006 I've helped companies of all sizes from startups to global brands such as Adobe, Dell and Ingersoll-Rand, create customer-centric programs, content and experiences. A long-time internet geek, I've been online since 1988 and began using social networking sites in 1991 when I joined Prodigy. Today, I help companies understand how new technologies like web3, crypto and artificial intelligence can integrate with existing marketing strategies to lead to exceptional customer experiences.

Comments

  1. jerome pineau says

    January 20, 2016 at 9:59 am

    “This thinking is soooo backwards and lazy.” – I’d go do far as calling it criminal actually.

  2. Marilyn - Social Butterfly says

    March 18, 2016 at 12:08 pm

    So true Mark. When a brand/company decides to only work with a blog outlet based on numbers alone it tells me various things. They do not fully understand or maybe not care about things like funnels, marketing, rapport building/maintaining, relationship maintaining, customer acquisition/retention, story branding, and other things.

Recent Posts

  • Understanding Substack’s Three Growth Stages
  • Blogging Isn’t Dead, it’s Morphed Into Substack
  • The Backstage Pass is Moving to Substack
  • Easter and the Three Eternal Gifts God Gives to Christians
  • Research: 97% of Loyalty Programs Fail Due to This Simple Design Flaw

Categories

Archives

Comment Policy

Be nice, be considerate, be friendly. Any comment that I feel doesn't meet these simple rules can and probably will be deleted.

Top Posts & Pages

  • Understanding Substack's Three Growth Stages
  • Why Did Jesus Send His Apostles Out With Nothing?
  • The Difference Between a Brand Ambassador and a Brand 'Spokesperson'
  • How Much Money Will You Make From Writing a Book?
  • How Much Does a Brand Ambassador Program Cost?
  • I Do Not Deserve to Suffer Like This...
  • The Difference Between Passive and Active Fans of Your Brand
  • 10 Things You Can Do TODAY to Make Your Blog Better
  • Case Study: Patagonia’s Brand Ambassador Program Focuses on Product Design and Development Over Sales
  • Let's Take a Closer Look at Patagonia's Worn Wear Road Tour

  • Blog
  • Mack’s Bio
  • Work With Mack
  • Buy Think Like a Rock Star
  • Book Mack to Speak

Copyright © 2025 · Executive Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

%d